In late Feb. 2011, the Denver Nuggets traded their two best players, Carmelo Anthony and Chauncey Billups, to the New York Knicks in exchange for centerpieces Wilson Chandler, Danilo Gallinari and Timofey Mozgov, as well as a handful of first and second-round draft picks. The 13-player, three-team trade went down as one of the most expansive and expensive in NBA history and was an early catalyst in spurring a league-wide trend that saw disgruntled superstars demand relocation from small-market franchises to the coastal metropolises of New York and Los Angeles.
Six years later a familiar story is unfolding between the Nuggets and Knicks, only this time the roles have been reversed: It’s the Knicks who now wish to unload their “superstar” and the Nuggets, armed with a stockpile of young talent and draft picks, looking to capitalize on the “disgruntled superstar” archetype.
Oh how times have changed, and yet how they have so ironically remained the same.
Unfortunately — or fortunately, depending on how you look at it — Nuggets management may have arrived at a red-or-blue-pill moment not entirely on their own behalf. In just the last few weeks reports have surfaced claiming Jusuf Nurkic is almost certain to be dealt by the trade deadline due to displeasure with his current role and in the last 24 hours, similar reports have emerged with regards to the usually sanguine Wilson Chandler, the longest tenured Nugget on the roster alongside Gallinari.
The opportunity for a major roster overhaul has come and passed many times over since the Knicks trade six years ago, a deal that afforded the Nuggets tremendous depth which has never quite been ironed out. The NBA more than any other major professional sport is based entirely on a caste system: generals precede lieutenants who precede majors who precede colonels and on down the line. LeBron James is flanked by Kyrie Irving who’s flanked by Kevin Love who’s flanked by Tristan Thompson and, well, you get the point.
Despite this understanding, the Nuggets have made one lateral move after the other, shipping a player here or there in exchange for someone, or draft picks, of equal value. Granted, the vast majority of these deals have worked in Tim Connelly’s favor and many were more than necessary to rebuild the chasm left in Masai Ujiri’s absence. But the fact remains: Connelly has made the same type of trade throughout his entire three-and-a-half-year career in Denver (never more than a single regular contributor was shipped out at a time) when what the Nuggets needed most was a virtual exodus to upgrade just a single position on the floor.
Though all actions have consequences, so do inactions. For Connelly and his team, the inability to boldly commit a massive and much-needed roster shuffle is an inaction that’s resulted in an overcrowded unit with a faction of malcontents who would rather be elsewhere and a coach left to play psychologist-mediator rather than captain of a basketball team. The chickens, as they say, have finally come home to roost.
The goods news for Connelly is that after years of conservatism he has no other choice but to turn radical. The Nuggets are more overcrowded than ever, more confused than ever and most importantly, more displeased than ever. What was collateral damage from the infamous Knicks trade six years ago is now finally manifesting in the form of mass dissatisfaction, and without proper intervention a revolt is sure to follow.
So how does Connelly go about remedying this predicament before it fully metastasizes? Simple: Be bold. Swing for the fences. Take a chance. Make a risky judgment call and trust your gut. Connelly has proven his worth as a GM and he is without question one of the better talent evaluators in the league. He has more than earned the right to wager whatever number of assets the Nuggets possess in an attempt to diversify and enliven a fairly monochromatic roster.
Start with Jusuf Nurkic. He has to go. Even better — he wants to go. It doesn’t matter his value at this point because it’s not getting any better with a team he doesn’t want to play for anymore. At just 22-years-old, he still has his entire career ahead of him and will undoubtedly mature and improve. Many teams around the league should be salivating at a chance to give this kid proper tutelage and a steady helping of minutes each night.
Next, do away with Emmanuel Mudiay, whom the Nuggets are reportedly seeking appraisal for on the open market, and rightfully so. Mudiay turns 21 next month and though still an infant by NBA standards he’s also been one of the worst players in the entire league since his debut. He can’t shoot, can’t defend, can’t create for others, has a sloppy handle and doesn’t understand how to play point guard at the NBA level. Could all these red flags magically disappear out of the blue after he plays 200 games in the NBA as opposed to 100? Theoretically. But why take the chance on watching another point guard’s value diminish (see: Ty Lawson) when you already have a savvy veteran in Jameer Nelson and a promising rookie in Jamal Murray?
Finally, cut ties with either Chandler or Gallinari for good. Choose one and do everything you can to keep the other satisfied. If Chandler wants more time, jettison Gallinari who’s in the final year of his contract and might jump ship this summer anyhow. If Chandler wants out no matter what, so be it. Package him with Nurkic, Mudiay or perhaps Faried and do everything you can to retain Gallinari come free agency. But whatever the case, pick a lane and floor it: Gallinari or Chandler. Let the connection at the hip end once and for all.
Between Nurkic, Mudiay, Chandler, Faried, depth at shooting guard and future draft picks, the Nuggets have perhaps the most superfluous roster in the entire NBA and one that is now boiling with indignation. The time for a trade is now. Connelly waited until he could not wait any longer and now he has no choice but to execute the long-awaited roster consolidation that was created when the Nuggets sent their two best players to New York in exchange for four of a somewhat, at the time at least, similar ilk. Perhaps now, after six wigwagging years, it will take yet another blockbuster trade for the Nuggets to come full circle, cut ties with the last strand of the Knicks trade and address their original sin of paying the price for winning with a superstar in a small market.

0 Comments (3 conversations)
Rhett Rothberg
How do you fix the apparent blind spot that lead to Mudiay in the first place? The team and the media that covers it were telling us all that the Mudiay pick was a steal. Well it turns out the 6 teams in front of the Nuggets were smart and the Nuggets weren’t.
Kalen Deremo
AuthorMudiay played really well in his first Summer League stint so I think there was a lot of hype around him early on. He also had some impressive outings last season, as well as some stinkers, which were probably written off as rookie lulls. What’s become clear in Year 2 is that those lulls probably weren’t due to him being a rookie as much as just being a mediocre basketball player.
Tim Connelly’s record in the draft might be better than anyone in the 3.5 years he’s been a GM. His 2014 draft was an absolute masterpiece and 2016 looks to be similarly impressive. As time goes on 2015 appears to be quite the enigma, not just from the Nuggets’ standpoint but across the board. It was supposed to be one of the best lotteries in years and yet so many of those players haven’t panned out. It’s still early to make definitive judgment calls but I’d say Connelly, like most everyone else, had a difficult time navigating that one. I was over the moon for Justise Winslow and Stanley Johnson and yet even Mudiay has put up better numbers than those two.
Bottom line is that despite the advances is statistics and technology the draft is still largely a crapshoot. You can’t yet account for which genes make a great ball player and which lead to busts. Even the best GMs whiff from time to time and unfortunately those instances can occur in the early lottery when you most need to succeed.
I actually think the news about Denver seeing what they could fetch for Mudiay is a great sign. It means they aren’t dogmatic and can recognize their mistakes early on in the hopes of selling while value is still high.
Connelly will undoubtedly swing and miss again but so do all GMs. It’s those who recognize their mistakes and correct them that separate the good from the great.
Also, I think Mudiay could help his value to the Nuggets by focusing on being an impact player on defense. The Nuggets already have enough potential on offense. Yet, against the Spurs, Ginobili schooled Mudiay with jumpers because he did not close out well enough. Overall, Mudiay says that he hates to lose, but his sense of urgency on
the court does not show that very well. With his size and strength, Mudiay has an opportunity to define more of his role on the defensive end.
The first priority should be to cut ties with mudiay. At this point he is a complete and total bust. I don’t think he could even get another contract in China. If chandler wants to go, so be it. I think farried is worth holding on to. If we just got rid of mudiay and had a starting caliber point guard, we could compete on a nightly basis. And please stop showing mudiay’s three point game winning shot against the 76ers last year on altitude commercial breaks.
This article is fine, and makes a point, but it almost assumes that Connelly isn’t already doing this. Yes it’s true the nuggets have a lot of “good” talent, and yes they could seemingly unload 4 or 5 players for a super star. But the real question is which team would take this trade and who is willing to come to Denver? It’s not like Tim can just say, “oh I want to get a super star, so I finally better let go of all this talent I’ve been holding on to.” Of course I don’t know what goes on behind closed doors in the front office, but I have to believe that he has tried on numerous occasions to make the nuggets better. Should he take a chance? Should he trade pieces that don’t want to be here or haven’t panned out? Yes of course, but that’s obvious, and entirely unhelpful to point out. Far better would be concrete possibilities as to who in the NBA wants these players and what superstar is actually upset or willing to come to or sign with Denver. Of which I can honestly think of none. So once again, talk about denver needing a super star, talk that’s been going on in this town for years and years, is empty and unrealistic. They have to do what they’ve done, build and find one through the draft.