The Colorado Avalanche dropped a crucial road game to the Vegas Golden Knights 4-1. Below are player grades for the brave and bold.
Mark Alt (C+) – You know what? This guy hasn’t been so shabby so far. I can live with this. He almost scored in the first! That would have been wild.
Tyson Barrie (D) – Over the years, I’ve listened to a certain section of Avs fans pine for Barrie to play forward. With the Avs losing in the third, you might have been convinced they had made the change with as often as he was breaking up the ice and trying to make something happen. I get it, but come on.
Gabriel Bourque (C+) – The 11 forward thing has boosted my appreciation of Bourque’s game. He’s usually out there now with at least one skill player and it’s kind of a wild time. Bad things aren’t happening and I’ll take that with the fourth line.
Blake Comeau (B-) – Loved the power move to the net on the game’s only goal. No surprise, getting Fleury moving and a rebound was the goal that beat him. Beyond that, Comeau was fine.
J.T. Compher (C-) – Some good, some bad with Compher on this night. The lack of finish from that line is a serious, serious problem.
Samuel Girard (B) – I really liked what Girard brought to the table tonight. He was flying all around and making things happen, especially defensively. Solid night for him until the third period, which is a caveat that applies to everybody.
Erik Johnson (D) – Some great from EJ tonight. The goal was great, he made some good decisions early, but his puck management completely fell apart in the third period when the Avs needed it the most.
Tyson Jost (C-) – Not a great night for Jost. There were some moments but it’s going to be remembered for his six penalty minutes, arguably none of which he really earned. His first penalty was a weak call and the second, while correct by the letter of the law, is a tough call to make when Jost had his stick lifted into someone else’s face.
Alexander Kerfoot (C-) – This line just hasn’t produced enough. Frustrating. Kerfoot seemed to disappear a bit in a faster environment, which surprised me a bit. I thought he’d handle the uptempo pace a little better than he did.
Gabriel Landeskog (C+) – I thought there were some great moments from the top line tonight but their inability to finish was a glaring problem. Obviously.
Anton Lindholm (INC) – Five minutes of ice time? That’s not worth grading, though I didn’t have any issues with him.
Nathan MacKinnon (C) – There were some dangerous moments but I was actually surprised to see he had four shots on goal after the game. It didn’t seem like he was creating as much havoc as he did on Saturday.
Patrik Nemeth (D+) – Frustrated with some poor play at even strength and on the penalty kill tonight. I didn’t like his game.
Matt Nieto (C-) – He picked up an assist but beyond that I really felt like he was a ghost tonight. Very low impact. He continues to be an odd fit for this lineup.
Mikko Rantanen (D) – The top line wasn’t good enough tonight and I thought Rantanen was the worst of the bunch. He was swimming all over the ice and losing pucks. His play on the power play was downright detrimental. Just a bad, bad night.
Carl Soderberg (D) – He should be a big body that does work in these kinds of games. Instead, he played a small man’s game and when he happened to come across chances on offense, misplayed the chances so poorly that it never got close to amounting to anything. Major letdown from the man they call ‘Carl’.
Dominic Toninato (C+) – I liked his game. He was physical and looked okay. He had a real NHL-caliber scoring chance in the first period. I’d love to see him actually bury one of those someday…
Semyon Varlamov (C+) – Varly wasn’t the reason they lost and there’s a legitimate conversation to be had about what he could have done differently on each of the goals to have a better chance of stopping them.
Nikita Zadorov (C-) – His puck management was pretty poor tonight and he botched a couple of intriguing offensive chances. I didn’t mind his defense for the most part although it was weird to see Barrie bail him out early on. Every game will probably feel like a letdown after the night he recorded 15 hits but that’s just unfair.

0 Comments (4 conversations)
BHGodlyGovt
I appreciate your grade of Varly after this game. I don’t remember exactly which game, but I argued that your grade of him was too low because neither of the goals that got past him he really could have stopped, so it was nice to see you give him a C+ this time instead of the D or D- you gave him the last time he had a similar game. Maybe the Nashville game? Don’t remember… lol
BHGodlyGovt
Found it, lol. It was the Nashville game, and you gave him a C. Would have still given him a B or B- instead of a C that game, but at least you gave him a C+ this time. Lol
Dan G
The reason I’d give Varly a higher grade is because the guys in front of him were just so awful in the third. In the third, he needed to match Fleury’s first-period effort, but that’s a very tall order and doesn’t mean he only deserves an ‘average’ grade. Even if Varly had made one more save (and I agree he should have at least stopped either goal #2 or #3 by Vegas) it would not have mattered, because the Avs were only able to put 4 shots on goal that period. The skaters couldn’t finish (yet again) in the first and could even muster an offense in the third.
AvsFinn
Varly ducked on the second goal. Hard to accept hard to believe. Goalies tend to react with their glove or blocker to shots like that but can’t remember when I’d seen an NHL goalie just yield.
I’m glad I’m not the only one who saw that. And I agree, I’ve never seen it before.
Nels
Pekka Rinne ducked Jake Guentzel’s shot in the cup finals last year.
AvsFinn
If you refer to the goal in game one, Rinne’s movement looks a bit similar but the shot is not coming towards his head.
JDC15
This stretch of tough games shows just how reliant this team is on the top line, if they don’t produce they are going to struggle to win. At the very least down these final games would like to see anybody emerge as a secondary scoring threat after the top line and Barrie. It would be a great time to see Jost show that he can be the 2C.