This will be a tough postmortem to perform, if, as it appears more and more likely, exactly how and why the Avalanche fell apart so badly in the second half of this season and missed the playoffs.
I don’t really get it, folks. On Dec. 6, the Avalanche had a 17-7-5 record after a 5-2 win at the BB&T Center in Sunrise, Fla. I was there that night, and I remember the overriding thought I had on the ride back to my Airbnb after writing the story of the game: What seed will the Avs be when the postseason starts?
The Avs were a genuinely exciting team to be around that night. They had a dominant first line, a more improved defense from the playoff squad of a season before, a seemingly strong 1-2 combo in goal and what was an unmistakable air of swagger in the dressing room. Not only that, there was the knowledge that Ottawa’s first-round pick would be theirs in 2019, along with D-men prospects such as Cale Makar and Conor Timmins on the way, plus a bunch of other draft picks.
“This is gonna be fun,” one player confidently told me, in forecasting the near-term future and beyond.
Friday night, the Avalanche dressing room was a morgue. When the final horn sounded on the shocking last-minute collapse and 5-3 loss to the lowly Anaheim Ducks, Avalanche players on the ice all hunched over with their sticks on their knees. That is the time-worn posture of players who know the season just ended.
Technically, it’s not over. But it’s over for the Avs of 2018-19. How did such a young, talented and, most important, confident team from that night in Sunrise see the sun set on its season already? How did this particular Avs team manage to go 13-22-5 after that night? How did we get here?
Barring a miracle, it’ll be a long, painful summer of trying to figure that out.
“If we want to be a playoff team, we’ve got to deserve it, you know? Right now, it doesn’t look like we deserve to be in the playoffs,” said Avs defender Nikita Zadorov, who looked like the frustrated hockey version of Rodin’s The Thinker after the game, staring vacantly into the floor. “It’s hard to win when you don’t play hard for 60 minutes. It’s been hurting us all year. We had a great first period, pretty good third period, but we totally lost the second period. We give up three goals (after getting a 2-0 lead). That’s totally unacceptable I think…We’ve all got to look in the mirror and figure it out.”
The final two minutes and 21 seconds of this game gives something of a big-picture answer of how it all went wrong. A microscosm of the season, since Dec. 6 at least, right in those 141 seconds: A late penalty, an errant stick by Mikko Rantanen, Anaheim on the power play in a 3-3 game. A pretty good PK for the first 1:24, clearing the puck a couple of times, until a defensive breakdown; A pass from the half-boards between the legs of Zadorov, over to the other side of the ice. A late-reacting Avs defense from there. Some scrambling around. A shot on net, stopped by Semyon Varlamov, but a rebound laying in the crease back toward Corey Perry on the other side.
Corey Perry may be old and slowing down, but he doesn’t miss 1-footers with nobody on him. A spirited Avs rally on the ensuing faceoff, a golden chance for J.T. Compher to tie it back up. A point, and maybe another to come, and the Avs are back to within three points of the last playoff spot. But Compher is stopped. Empty-net goal. Game over, Avs players hunched over.
And, probably, season over.
“(Bleep) happens. It’s hockey sometimes. I take responsibility for that,” Rantanen told BSN Denver. “I don’t know. It is what it is I guess.”
Jared Bednar was one pretty frustrated looking man afterward.
“We were checking with our eyes,” Bednar said. “We gotta check with our legs. We were the rested team, but we didn’t win enough races. We didn’t check the puck back enough. We build a lead and it looked like we got comfortable with it, and we stopped working.”
Bednar was plenty critical of his players in the macro sense, but he knows he could be the one blamed for all of this. I don’t think he’s going to be fired over this season, but am I totally confident of that? Uh, this is the NHL. So, no.
I asked him if he’s had to look in the mirror himself over what’s happened and wonder if it’s his message that isn’t working anymore?
“Yeah. We evaluate every day,” Bednar said. “The players, as a staff, what we have to do, what we want to do. We needed a big effort tonight and we got it from some guys and partially from other guys. But that’s a skill; Being consistent is a skill, as a player. We have good players. We have really good players. But being able to do it every night is a skill. We’ve got to work on it. We’ve got to mature to the point where we’re good every night, not just once in a while.”
This game was another microcosm, in the sense that the Avs just didn’t play with any killer instinct, against a team it should have beaten easily. Too many teams came into the Pepsi Center this year and outworked an Avs club that had no excuses for that to be the case. This was a Ducks team that played the night before in Arizona, was playing its third game in four nights and an Avs team that had been off since Monday.
Just like in the season, they got out to a good start in this one, then let up. Then, they played with desperation after losing their cushion. But it was too late.
Why a team that still hasn’t won a playoff round in 11 full years, a team that seemed hungry for more after that unexpected run to the playoffs in 2017-18 but instead fell back into the deadly trap of self-satisfaction?
It’s a mystery, with no good solution, at the moment.

0 Comments (13 conversations)
jbame
Bednar has got to go. 17-7-5 start and 13-22-5 since? Holy hell.
Hockeyhead
Good call Adrian, the deadly trap of self-satisfaction. This game epitomized the Avalanche’s season, play well, get complacent and self-satisfied and then totally blow it. Until they develop the fire and desire to compete every night for 60 minutes every game, they will be a frustrating team to be a fan of. Hopefully, they will learn how to be a consistently high performing team next season. Hopefully, the players that need to take the next step up in their game will. Hopefully, the players who didn’t play to their level will. On and on.
AllezAllezAllez
Bednar probably survives this season. The assistants however….should update their resumes.
tele_mon
Thank you for a a realistic perspective. I think they really missed Gabe tonight, not that it should have mattered. Brutal night for the organization and the fans.
ljp78
Blaming Bednar for players who are self satisfied is too easy. It’s the players fault, plain and simple. Who was relaxing? Those guys need to answer. If they’re not part of the solution, then the Avs have some really tough questions to ask this off season. Because this is not a new issue for this franchise. Something needs to change, and I don’t think it’s Bednar.
Sarasota Curt
I have followed this team since the beginning and this has to be one of the most frustrating seasons of all. There’s plenty of blame to go around, i.e., lack of offensive depth and spotty goaltending and defense. You can’t win with one great line. This isn’t the NBA. But I have to start with the head coach and he must go. There’s no way around it and no reason in my mind to begin another season with Bednar behind the bench. Coach Q, where are you?
And btw, AD, excellent piece, but it’s Rodin’s The Thinker, not Rodan the monster.
Justin
I am officially jumping on the Bendnar must go wagon. 3 years is a good trial period, and 1 out of 3 good seasons is just not good enough. I know the excuses for season 1, with him coming in late, but that doesn’t explain just HOW bad that season was. The experimenting with new coaches isn’t working either, bring in an established pro like Q. I was upset when they let him go in the first place, and CHI was pretty much what the AVS are now when he joined them. Make it happen Joe!
mladen
A coach has to have some control over his players minds and heart. Unfortunately Bednar does not.
Eidolon
That’s a super-high level of stupid comment right there. Hyperbole at it’s finest. How does one man control the mind and hearts of 23 other grown men? I’m not a Bednar apologist, but if professional athletes who are otherwise prepared to play can’t get mentally ready or motivated to do their job, that’s on the players. You evaluate Bednar’s impact through his schemes, his matchups, his choice of players in situations, and his ability to maximize players within the team concept, not his ability to “control hearts and minds.” He’s not a telepath or a deity.
JDC15
I agree with your assessment about motivation. If the damn pay check isn’t enough and you need someone to motivate you, you need a new job.
This is a team I thought turned a serious corner pushing the Preds in the playoffs short handed, and starting the season hard. But where is that killer instinct? They had the Ducks on the ropes begging to be put out of their mercy and what did they do, rolled over and got their asses handed to them. Out scored 5-1 in the last 2 periods at HOME against a team traveling and playing back to backs. Ridiculous.
mladen
You’re too stupid to see the reality. If you ever played sports you would understand the players have to buy in to what the coach is telling them and selling them. That’s control moron.
ahinton54
Eidolon: A super-high level of stupid? Dude that shows how little you know about the psychology of leadership in team sports.
Eidolon
Some serious revisionist history in this comment.
Adrian Dater
AuthorAgh. Thanks. I knew something looked off when I wrote that
Eidolon
So explain what Bednar did differently between those two sets of numbers?
jbame
Playing Bourque Nemeth and Cole over Graves and Greer for one. How about never giving Francouz a start when he clearly deserved it?
jpwheels
I would have liked to see Graves and Greer play more too. But I highly doubt those guys being in the lineup would’ve have changed the W/L record since early December much at all. Same goes for playing/not playing Nemeth, Cole, and Francouz when he was up.
Although he has a voice in the conversation, Bednar doesn’t make the call on player AHL/NHL movement.
TheHoppyHacker
Nothing different.
KCRybek
I’m looking forward to year 37 of the rebuild next year
Eagle_Avs
Love this comment. Funny, but so true.
Chris
What’s the latest on Timmons??
Adrian Dater
AuthorSame
gtq
Good coaching always makes a difference. Even with the deficiencies this team has things should not have gotten as and as they have. Just because someone is an adult and well paid doesn’t mean they don’t need coaching. You want examples of Bednar deficiencies? Here is a long list of things that he and HIS STAFF failed to do well. Sins of the coaching staff also attach to the head coach.
1. Penalty kill was terrible this year. Last year was the first time it had been decent in awhile and they made the playoffs. This year it contributed to them not making the playoffs. That’s coaching.
2. We took more penalties than any team in the league. This is an undersized team built on speed. How on earth does a team with that DNA lead the league in penalties? Coaching. Frequent penalties plus bad PK equals failure.
3. Our two goaltenders were terrible in January and February and it cost us games when just an average performance would have gotten us a win. Both goaltenders historically have been fairly good. Somebody was not prepping them properly.
4. Frequent miscommunications in coverage on the backend of transition breaks. Two guys chasing the puck and leaving someone wide open. 70 games into the season. Players make mistakes, but good coaches demand they correct them. Bednar throwing his hands up in the air at a press conference and saying we are making the same mistakes we were at the beginning of the year is a self indictment. Coaching.
5. At one time we were 1-12 in OT. Our approach during those games was insane. All 3 players over committing to the offensive end and getting caught flat footed 5 seconds later. Only when we changed up a couple of games ago did we have any success in OT. It shouldn’t have taken 12 games and 12 lost points to make that adjustment. Coaching.
6. We had a stretch when our power play went dry for 10 games and it killed us. Why. Because we rolled out the same scheme that we did in the first 50 games and by then teams knew how to take it away. Lack of adjustments. Coaching.
I can go on. You can blame the players, but a good coach doesn’t let the players get away with making the same mistakes game after game. I don’t sense he has any control over the stars on this team. They do what they want – Rantanen with the nonstop minor penalties; McKinnon with the casual defense and piss poor faceoff performance. A better coach makes his most talented players upgrade their games. I am not seeing it.
Colorado_Gary
Yep. Time and again we see teams come in and play systems that frustrate the Avs. No adjustments from the Avs staff, just more of the same or play a crappy system harder. That’s what frustrates the players, being told to play harder in a bad system. Mistakes are repeated without being corrected. Once the league figured out how to play the Avs, the slide started.
Bednar must go. Bring in Q.
Pucklehead
Well said gtq…also coaching is more difficult w/less talented , dare I say less hockey smart players
Lefseeter
Doesn’t the coach have limited practice time to fix problems? I’ve often wondered if that was hard adjustment for new nhl coaches, without experience.
ThePhotoGorilla
I still think much of this is because there doesn’t seem to be any leadership outside of Landy, which is odd considering we have a couple of ex-captains on the roster.